Feasibility and effectiveness of global intact forest landscape protection through forest certification: the conservation burden of intact forest landscapes

Author(s): Zwerts, J.A. van der Linde, C.M. Praamstra, G.J. Schipper, J. Trolliet, F.
+ 2
Publication Year: 2024
Publication Type: Journal Article
Source: Frontiers in Forests and Global Change (7, 1335430)
Code:
Access to the Study: Open link
Permanent Resource Identifier: Open link
FSC Resource Identifier:
Collections: FSC Research Portal
Abstract

Intact Forest Landscapes (IFLs) are defined as forested areas of at least 500 km2 that show no signs of remotely sensed human activity. They are considered to be of high conservation value due to their role in maintaining biodiversity and mitigating climate change. In 2014, the members of the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC), one of the major global certification schemes for responsible forest management, took a conservation stand by restricting logging in FSC-certified IFLs. However, this move raised concerns about the economic viability of FSC-certified logging in these areas. To address these challenges, in 2022, FSC proposed an integrated landscape approach, considering local conditions and stakeholders� needs to balance IFL protection, economic sustainability, and community interests. Here, we leverage publicly available management unit (MU) data, to provide a global quantitative overview of IFLs designated for timber production. We use the concept of �conservation burden� for the extent that MUs overlap with IFLs, representing the impact that IFL protection has on forest management operations if logging is disallowed. Our data indicates that currently FSC-certified MUs affect 0.6% of global IFLs. Too restrictive policies for logging in IFLs may discourage FSC-certification in global IFLs. Considering the environmental and social benefits of FSC certification, it warrants careful examination whether the benefits of protecting a limited subset of FSC-certified IFLs outweighs the cost of potentially reduced growth of the total FSC-certified area. Our data can provide a basis to facilitate stakeholder engagement for landscape-level IFL management.

Summary
Sponsors
Citation
Sustainability dimension(s): 2. Environmental
Subject Keywords:
Regions: Global
Countries: NS
Forest Zones: Boreal, Tropical
Forest Type: Natural Forest
Tenure Ownership: NS
Tenure Management: NS
Evidence Category: FSC relevant studies
Evidence Type: Meta-analysis
Evidence Subtype:
Data Type: FSC data archive, Non-FSC data archive, Remote sensing