Open Knowledge (FSC OK)

The article examines how the interplay between domestic regulations and third-party compliance assessment shapes the effects of transnational non-state environmental certification and labelling, which has become an important part of the global environmental and natural resource governance. Based on an extensive qualitative case study of forest certification by the Forest Stewardship Council in Russia, the article argues, first, that Russia's extensive domestic regulations have restricted the impact of forest certification on forest companies because of significant contradictions between national forest law and global certification standards and the poorly implemented ongoing reform of the national forest governance. Second, the article shows that in this challenging environment, the ability of third-party certifiers to enforce and control the implementation of certification standards is critical, but has been increasingly undermined by the emerging price competition between certifiers, the resulting lack of resources for proper control and the diminishing capacity of environmental stakeholders to monitor certifiers effectively.